HARE Irrigation Project · Hydrological Analysis

Rational Method (Q = CIA)

GIS-based estimation of the weighted runoff coefficient at the HARE diversion weir, integrating ArcMap land use, SWAT slope classes and the project's soil-group assignment. Calculations are shown with source assumptions and reproducible arithmetic.

Composite C ≈ 0.318 Weir catchment: 163.89 km² 26 combined raster classes Screening estimates · not final design

Combined GIS analysis — infographic

This explanatory infographic is adapted from the supplied ArcMap combined-raster screenshot and the calculations used to derive the project screening coefficient; use the original GIS raster for spatial measurements. The 26 unique colors represent land-use, slope-band and soil combinations, not 26 separate land-use categories.

HARE Weir combined GIS map and step-by-step weighted Rational runoff coefficient calculation, including land use, slope, soil group C and 25/50-year screening discharge
Figure: GIS-based weighted Rational Method runoff coefficient for the HARE Weir catchment, using ArcMap combined_S_S_LU.tif. Source: HARE GIS analysis / Team1995 · harewater.org. Note that the 50-year intensity and peak-discharge calculation are provisional.

1. GIS input data and preparation

  1. Land cover: use the LUweir raster with codes for trees (2), cropland (5), built-up (7), bare ground (8), cloud-obscured land (10) and rangeland (11).
  2. Slope: derive slope bands from the DEM/SWAT LandSlope2 raster. The classes are 1 (0–5%), 2 (5–15%), 3 (15–30%), 4 (30–60%) and 999 (60% or steeper). Code 999 is a real slope class, not missing data.
  3. Soil: use the mapped SWAT soil unit To6-2bc-257, whose HYDGRP field records C and TEXTURE records LOAM. This is a project soil-group assignment, not a numerical Rational coefficient.
  4. Combine: ArcMap Spatial Analyst → Local → Combine produced combined_S_S_LU.tif with 26 unique land-use–slope–soil combinations.
  5. Raster area: output cell size 12.46159901 × 12.46159901 m. Area per cell = (X × Y) / 10,000 = 0.015529145 ha.
Combined raster area16,194.55 ha161.95 km²
Independent weir delineation16,388.67 ha163.8867 km²
Earlier HEC-HMS basin model162.035 km²A different model-boundary figure

Three different area figures occur in the project records. The raster area is used to estimate C; the independently delineated upstream catchment is used here for Q. The earlier five-subbasin HEC-HMS model area is recorded for traceability, not silently substituted.

Land-use areas measured from the combined raster

Land coverCodeArea (ha)Share (%)
Cropland58,225.4550.79
Rangeland113,999.0324.69
Trees / forest22,365.9914.61
Built-up7922.075.69
Cloud-obscured10681.994.21
Bare ground80.020.00
Total16,194.55100.00

Slope distribution from the same raster

Slope bandSWAT codeArea (ha)Share (%)
0–5%1466.402.88
5–15%22,645.6516.34
15–30%35,532.7434.16
30–60%45,994.7537.02
≥60%9991,555.019.60
Total16,194.55100.00

2. Coefficient assignment and area weighting

For the preliminary screening exercise, runoff coefficients were assigned for each mapped land-use–slope combination with the project's uniform hydrologic soil group C as context. The values below are project screening assumptions, not a table of exact coefficients prescribed by FHWA. The original mapping and slope bands remain preserved.

Land cover0–5%5–15%15–30%30–60%≥60%
Trees / forest0.150.200.250.300.35
Cropland0.200.250.300.350.40
Built-up0.550.600.650.700.75
Bare ground0.400.450.500.550.60
Rangeland0.150.200.250.300.35
Areaᵢ (ha) = COUNTᵢ × (12.46159901² / 10,000)
C_Areaᵢ = Cᵢ × Areaᵢ
Cweighted = Σ(Cᵢ × Areaᵢ) / Σ(Areaᵢ)
Valid classified area (21 combinations)15,512.56 ha
Σ(C × Area), confirmed in ArcMap4,933.086807
Calculated coefficient0.318006≈ 0.318
Cweighted = 4,933.086807 / 15,512.559862 = 0.318006

Verification: ArcMap Statistics for the 21 valid rows returned SUM(C_Area) = 4,933.086807 and SUM(Area_ha) = 15,512.559862, reproducing the same weighted result.

Show the full 26-combination GIS calculation table
#Land coverSlopeCOUNTArea (ha)Assigned CC × Area
1Cropland5–15%95,6011,484.60180.25371.1504
2Cropland0–5%15,152235.29760.2047.0595
3Cropland15–30%212,4893,299.77250.30989.9317
4Cropland30–60%180,6602,805.49530.35981.9234
5Rangeland15–30%63,560987.03250.25246.7581
6Rangeland5–15%26,756415.49780.2083.0996
7Rangeland0–5%4,07363.25020.159.4875
8Rangeland30–60%123,1851,912.95770.30573.8873
9Trees / forest30–60%63,778990.41780.30297.1253
10Trees / forest15–30%36,908573.14970.25143.2874
11Trees / forest5–15%14,549225.93350.2045.1867
12Rangeland≥60%39,944620.29620.35217.1037
13Cropland≥60%25,776400.27920.40160.1117
14Trees / forest0–5%3,96961.63520.159.2453
15Trees / forest≥60%33,154514.85330.35180.1986
16Cloud-obscured30–60%12,171189.0052—Excluded
17Cloud-obscured≥60%1,19218.5107—Excluded
18Cloud-obscured15–30%19,249298.9205—Excluded
19Built-up5–15%23,507365.04360.60219.0262
20Cloud-obscured5–15%9,954154.5771—Excluded
21Built-up15–30%24,074373.84860.65243.0016
22Built-up0–5%5,48985.23950.5546.8817
23Built-up30–60%6,23896.87080.7067.8096
24Cloud-obscured0–5%1,35120.9799—Excluded
25Built-up≥60%691.07150.750.8036
26Bare ground15–30%10.01550.500.0078

Cloud-obscured rows are excluded from the classified-only calculation of C; their apparent C_Area = 0 is a placeholder, not an assertion of zero runoff.

3. Treatment of cloud-obscured and unrepresented land

The source image recorded 681.99 ha as cloud-obscured. Clouds are not a land-use class and were excluded when deriving C from known covers. Rather than omit that area from the screening discharge calculation, we provisionally extend the measured classified-land average C to the cloud-obscured area.

Imputed cloud contribution = 681.993460 × 0.318006 = 216.877999
Whole-raster C = (4,933.087 + 216.878) / 16,194.553 = 0.318006

The coefficient is numerically unchanged because the missing portion was assigned exactly the calculated mean. Applying the same coefficient to the additional 194.12 ha separating the raster and the independently delineated catchment is another provisional extrapolation, not a verified land-cover measurement.

Limitations: Reclassify cloud-obscured pixels with cloud-free imagery and harmonize boundary masks before final design. An area-weighted mean does not demonstrate that the unknown cells have average land-use characteristics.

4. Rational Method peak-flow screening

The metric Rational Method relationship is Q = 0.278 × C × I × A, where discharge Q is in m³/s, C is dimensionless, intensity I is mm/h, and contributing area A is km².

Q (m³/s) = 0.278 × C × I (mm/h) × A (km²)

The earlier time-of-concentration estimate was about 6.1 h. The reported 25-year intensity 11.33 mm/h comes from a six-hour rainfall duration, which is only an approximation to Tc. The 50-year intensity 12.44 mm/h is an unverified provisional historical input, not the updated IDF result.

25-year — older rainfall intensityQ₂₅ = 164.15 m³/s0.278 × 0.318006 × 11.33 × 163.8867
50-year — provisional rainfall intensityQ₅₀ = 180.24 m³/s0.278 × 0.318006 × 12.44 × 163.8867

Comparison with event-based modelling

Return periodRational MethodHEC-HMSInterpretation
25 years164.15 m³/s97 m³/s (earlier run)Different input generations; not a like-for-like verification
50 years180.24 m³/s (provisional)≈ 195 m³/s (updated reported peak)Provisional Rational estimate is 7.6% lower
Do not treat these discharge estimates as a validated design: the 50-year IDF intensity at Tc, slope/land-use-specific screening coefficients, cloud cover, catchment delineation and model run metadata must be verified. No runoff coefficient has been adjusted to force agreement with HEC-HMS. The conventional Rational Method is intended for much smaller catchments than HARE.

5. References and related technical material

Reference formulas and selection guidance are based on the Federal Highway Administration manuals. The GIS-derived areas and numerical coefficient table are project calculations, and the class-specific C assignments should be interpreted as local screening assumptions.

  • FHWA (2024a). Highway Hydrology, Hydraulic Design Series No. 2, 3rd ed. Official HDS-2 PDF ↗.
  • FHWA (2024b). Urban Drainage Design Manual, Hydraulic Engineering Circular No. 22, 4th ed. Official HEC-22 PDF ↗.
  • HARE Irrigation Project (2026). ArcMap combined_S_S_LU.tif, raster attributes and SWAT soil/slope datasets. Team1995 · harewater.org.