Engineering comparison

1995 Study vs Modern Models

The purpose of the modern reassessment is not to replace or erase the original 1995 HARE Irrigation Project analysis. The historical design is preserved as the engineering baseline, while HEC-HMS, SWAT and CROPWAT provide independent modern checks using updated datasets, GIS, hydrological modelling and FAO crop-water procedures.

Current flood-data status (IMERG 2000–2025). Gumbel-estimated 24-hour design rainfall is 70.18 mm (25-year) and 75.62 mm (50-year). The revised HEC-HMS 50-year outlet peak is 195.2 m³/s (provisional), with 27.86 mm runoff depth and approximately 4.513 million m³ runoff volume. This replaces the older 114.4 m³/s value as the current preliminary model result, not as a newly accepted design flood. The 25-year IMERG-based peak remains pending its dedicated HEC-HMS simulation.
Comparison principle. Agreement between the historical and modern results strengthens confidence in the original design. Differences are investigated in terms of climate period, data source, spatial resolution, modelling method and engineering assumptions rather than being treated automatically as errors.
Flood hydrology

Design Peak Flood Comparison

The original 1995 flood estimates are retained as the historical design benchmark. The modern HEC-HMS model is then used to independently derive event hydrographs and peak discharges for selected return periods. SWAT is used principally as a longer-term watershed model rather than as the primary design-flood model. The 1995 Log-Pearson Type III series, the earlier CHIRPS-based HEC-HMS simulation, and the newer IMERG-based HEC-HMS simulation use different data and methods and must not be interpreted as a like-for-like calibration.

Return period 1995 peak Q
(m³/s)
HEC-HMS
(m³/s)
SWAT / other check Interpretation
5 years 25.289 Not finalised SWAT is retained as a watershed-scale hydrological consistency check rather than the principal event-flood estimate. This return period will be added only after its final HEC-HMS simulation has been checked and accepted.
10 years 33.372 Not finalised SWAT is retained as a watershed-scale hydrological consistency check rather than the principal event-flood estimate. This return period will be added only after its final HEC-HMS simulation has been checked and accepted.
25 years 46.655 Not finalised SWAT is retained as a watershed-scale hydrological consistency check rather than the principal event-flood estimate. IMERG 25-year rainfall is 70.18 mm/24 h. The new outlet peak remains pending. The earlier CHIRPS-era 97.0 m³/s estimate is archived and is not a current design-flood result.
50 years 59.183 195.2 Provisional SWAT is retained as a watershed-scale hydrological consistency check rather than the principal event-flood estimate. IMERG 50-year storm: 75.62 mm/24 h. Provisional HEC-HMS outlet peak: 195.2 m³/s at Sink-1 / Hare Weir, compared with the 1995 estimate of 59.183 m³/s. Archived CHIRPS-era HEC-HMS peak: 114.4 m³/s.
100 years 74.397 Not finalised SWAT is retained as a watershed-scale hydrological consistency check rather than the principal event-flood estimate. This return period will be added only after its final HEC-HMS simulation has been checked and accepted.
Result-status clarification. The earlier 114.4 m³/s CHIRPS-based 50-year peak is an archived comparison result. The revised IMERG-based 50-year peak of 195.2 m³/s is provisional until the HEC-HMS recomputation warning is resolved and the outlet time series verified. The archived 25-year peak of approximately 97.0 m³/s is not a valid substitute for the pending 70.18 mm IMERG 25-year simulation. The 5-, 10- and 100-year modern peaks also remain unfinalised.
Hydrological interpretation. HEC-HMS provides the principal modern design-flood check because it is configured for event-based rainfall-runoff modelling. SWAT complements this by testing whether the rainfall, evapotranspiration, runoff and groundwater behaviour are hydrologically realistic over longer periods. A SWAT daily mean discharge must not be equated with a subdaily HEC-HMS event peak.
Watershed water balance

SWAT Hydrological Check

SWAT Simulation 2 represents continuous daily watershed behaviour using 2020–2025 meteorological forcing; 2020 is the model warm-up year and 2021–2025 is the interpretation period. These values are reported mean annual model outputs, not measurements or single-year totals. The simulations are complete, but formal streamflow and sediment calibration have not yet been completed.

SWAT parameter Simulation result Engineering meaning
Mean annual precipitation 1665.5 mm Average annual climatic input over the SWAT simulation period.
Potential ET 1570.7 mm Atmospheric evaporative demand estimated by the selected SWAT PET method.
Actual ET 928.9 mm Simulated evapotranspiration actually realised by the watershed.
Surface runoff 267.63 mm Direct surface contribution to watershed discharge.
Lateral flow 250.62 mm Subsurface lateral water movement toward the stream network.
Groundwater return flow 182.06 mm Simulated groundwater contribution to streamflow.
Average curve number 77.62 Represents the average runoff response of the simulated watershed.
Interpretation limit. SWAT Simulation 2 is an uncalibrated reference simulation. Its rainfall, flow and sediment diagnostics are model outputs and must not be treated as verified observed values or as a direct substitute for event-based HEC-HMS design floods.
Crop water demand

1995 Crop-Water Method vs Modern CROPWAT

The crop-water comparison is methodologically important because the original 1995 Hare study used the FAO procedures available at the time, while the reconstruction uses modern CROPWAT procedures. The physical basis remains similar: reference evapotranspiration is converted into crop evapotranspiration using crop coefficients, effective rainfall is deducted, and irrigation losses are added to determine diversion demand.

Component Hare 1995 Modern CROPWAT reconstruction Comparison objective
Reference ET Modified Penman method FAO Penman–Monteith procedure Compare annual magnitude and monthly seasonality.
Crop coefficient Kc values derived for crop-development stages Crop-specific Kc values entered in CROPWAT Check whether modern crop coefficients alter ETc.
Crop evapotranspiration ETc derived from ETo × Kc ETc = Kc × ETo Direct crop-by-crop comparison.
Effective rainfall Effective rainfall and storage-factor procedure CROPWAT effective-rainfall calculation Determine how much rainfall contributes to crop demand.
Net irrigation requirement NIR = ETc − Pe NIR calculated from ETc and effective rainfall Compare field-level irrigation requirement.
Conveyance efficiency 80% To be tested against reconstructed canal condition Determine effect of canal losses on diversion requirement.
Application efficiency 70% To be reviewed Compare field-application assumptions.
Field canal efficiency 80% To be reviewed Assess distribution losses.
ETc adjustment 20% reduction adopted in the 1995 design because of the humid environment associated with nearby lakes and vegetation No automatic reduction; modern climate data are used directly Test whether the historical adjustment remains justified.
Final output Monthly water requirement and diversion discharge ETc, effective rainfall, NIR, GIR, irrigation schedule and scheme discharge Compare modern scheme demand directly with the historical design.
2026 reconstructed scheme irrigation demand. For the 1,968.01 ha operational command, the calculated annual crop evapotranspiration is 22.814 MCM, net irrigation demand is 15.529 MCM and gross irrigation demand is 34.662 MCM at 44.8% overall efficiency. August is the peak-demand month (4.274 MCM). Dividing by its 31 calendar days gives 1.596 m³/s as the continuous-month equivalent, slightly exceeding the 1.55 m³/s canal capacity. The operating implication is rotational allocation and scheduling, not continuous unrestricted supply. These are reconstructed demand calculations; field verification and crop-input refinement remain distinct from calculation completion.
August conversion check. 4.274 million m³ ÷ (31 × 86,400 seconds) = 1.596 m³/s. The former 1.649 m³/s figure corresponds to a 30-day planning-month assumption; it should only be used if that convention is explicitly adopted. Monthly average flow is not the same as a peak instantaneous irrigation delivery rate.
CROPWAT climate and crop-water methods →
Climate and evapotranspiration

FAO Climate Reference vs SWAT

Parameter FAO historic climate SWAT simulation Interpretation
Climate period 1961–1990 2021–2025 (2020 warm-up) Different periods; direct rainfall equality is not expected.
Annual precipitation 811 mm 1665.5 mm These data represent different climate periods, sources and spatial scales; the difference must not be attributed to climate change without a like-for-like comparison.
Annual ETo / PET 1622 mm 1570.7 mm Annual magnitudes differ by about 3.2%; ETo and SWAT PET remain methodologically distinct quantities.
Important. FAO CROPWAT ETo and SWAT PET are not automatically identical quantities. Their close annual magnitudes are used here as a consistency check. The selected PET method in SWAT should be documented when the final technical comparison is prepared.